If some of WA’s biggest industrial gas buyers aren’t already considering quitting the State’s most influential lobby group, maybe they should be. The DomGas Alliance, the group of manufacturers demanding the State Government properly enforce WA’s long-standing gas reservation scheme, includes Alcoa, Yara Pilbara, Cockburn Cement and Tronox. All are also members of the Chamber of Minerals and Energy. Along with the State Government, the CME has given almost unequivocal support to a carve-out of WA from the Albanese Government’s new national reservation scheme. There’s been little acknowledgement of the counter narrative argued by the big gas buyers — that a carve-out was a “free pass” for LNG producers who are not meeting the intent of the State’s reservation policy by ensuring 15 per cent of their gas a year is made available for WA. With the Albanese Government this week granting a qualified carve-out, the DomGas members perhaps should ask how they reconcile their membership of the CME with its conflicting messaging. The Government and CME have barely deviated from the argument that a national reservation scheme is an unnecessary overlap on WA that, without an exclusion of the State, threatens investment. However, there’s little, if any, public acknowledgement of the DomGas members’ concerns that their own long-term investments in WA are potentially threatened by their inability to lock down long-term gas. DomGas, which also includes Wesfarmers’ significant chemical and fertiliser arm and Coogee Chemicals, have long argued it’s difficult to get visibility on costs and likely returns from a new project when they can’t secure better than one or two-year gas supply contracts. They want the Government to adopt the recommendations of the 2024 WA parliamentary inquiry into the domestic scheme to ensure that the big LNG producers are abiding by their commitments. It’s not enough to have a gas reservation policy. It has to deliver. The evidence is that the producers aren’t abiding by the intent of the scheme because they’re providing as little as 8 per cent of their gas a year for local buyers. Queried about the conflicting views of its DomGas members, the CME insists it consults “regularly” with “all its members” and reckons the domestic gas policy “largely gets the balance right”. It conceded it could be improved, but was reluctant to be even suggesting more gas needed to be delivered. Groupings such as DomGas are often made up of companies with conflicting interests, sometimes making it difficult to achieve consensus around how to sell your message. There’s nothing to show for all its lobbying, and the occasional public expression of frustration by individual members such as Wesfarmers barely registers with the Government. There’s no evidence so far that the Government is listening, let alone acting on their concerns by forcing the LNG producers to push more gas onto the market. Perhaps it’s time to change tack — and get more aggressive.
Sean Smith: Ignored DomGas companies should reconsider CME membership
How do some of WA’s biggest manufacturers reconcile their membership of the influential lobby group with the conflicting messaging by the CME.




