Stronger protections for tree canopy and historic public areas such as Irwin Barracks were the key concerns raised at this year’s annual general meeting of electors in Nedlands. Two motions passed at last Wednesday’s AGM will be considered by the City of Nedlands council at its meeting next month. A motion from Nedlands Tree Canopy Advocates secretary Martina Bovell that the council take a stronger stance on protecting mature trees was passed unanimously. Ms Bovell asked the city to publish its significant tree register, provide heritage protections for old growth trees, and recognise and protect significant trees on private land. “The city maintains a significant tree register for trees on city-controlled land on its website and asks residents to nominate trees for inclusion. However, the register is not publicly available, unlike those for example in the cities of Vincent and Mandurah,” she said. “Publishing the register and ensuring it is reviewed and updated at regular intervals would improve transparency, increase community awareness, and also encourage greater participation in protecting our valuable tree assets.” Ms Bovell asked why the city recognised heritage buildings such as Gallop House and Montgomery Hall, but not some of the “oldest trees” that pre-dated European settlement. “We seek for the council to provide heritage protection for old growth trees and other trees on the significant tree register by listing them in the city’s local planning scheme,” she said. “Our oldest trees and other significant trees deserve similar consideration as living heritage with the highest possible protections. An important example are the remnant tuarts: these are irreplaceable elements in our natural landscape.” The city adopted a policy to protect mature, regulated trees on private land in 2024. This includes trees that have a canopy diameter of at least 6m, trunk circumference of 1.5m or stand at least 8m tall. Ms Bovell said there was a “gap” in current arrangements and sought a new process that enabled trees on private land to be nominated for the register by property owners or members of the public, preventing private removals that had been going on “for years”. “A tree that may be of reasonable age, size, cultural or environmental significant yet may not qualify for protections afforded to the regulated trees. This can leave significant trees vulnerable during development,” she said. She encouraged Nedlands to follow the City of Vincent’s lead by examining approaches for broader protection for significant trees rather than relying solely on a WALGA tree retention policy. A motion via email from former councillor Fergus Bennett that chief executive Paul Martin provide advice on designating heritage areas over several public lands within the city was also passed. These areas include Irwin Barracks, Karrakatta Cemetery, Nedlands Foreshore and Allen Park. Cr Rebecca Coghlan said the areas in question were in the city’s municipal boundaries but on land owned either by the State or Commonwealth. “A local government may by resolution designate a heritage area where special planning control is needed to conserve and enhance cultural heritage significance supported by a mandatory local planning policy,” she said. “A heritage area carried in a scheme amendment and approved by the minister provides protection a resolution alone cannot.” Cr Julian Coleman said he couldn’t think of any heritage protections across Australia anyone regretted putting in place. “Particularly Irwin Barracks and Karrakatta Cemetery are magnificent places and I think heritage protections of these places is a gift to the future,” he said. Cr Stephen Kobelke said he understood the intent, but he didn’t want the city to be “locked in” to a long-term project. “I’m estimating that councillors are spending upwards of 35 hours a week working through concept plans trying to pull the city back, and my scope is this is a fairly extensive amount of work that’s required here,” he said. City officers said there would be “quite some work involved” to provide options to the council, but “that shouldn’t necessarily be a deterrent” as it could progress over several years. Annual general elector meetings are typically held earlier in the year. Nearby local councils Claremont, Cottesloe and Mosman Park all held theirs in February. Nedlands’ was held later than usual because the city did not receive the all-clear from the OAG until August after trying to sort out its finances following a failed annual audit in 2023.
Nedlands residents push city to protect trees and historic public spaces at annual general meeting
Stronger protections for tree canopy and heritage areas such as Irwin Barracks were the key concerns raised at this year’s annual general meeting of electors in Nedlands.


