Premium

Home / Business / Media Insider

Media Insider: New details revealed of RNZ CFO’s departure, what minister was told; Mark Sainsbury takes aim at TVNZ’s plan to ditch political editor role

NZME Editor-at-Large · NZ Herald ·

19 Nov, 2026 04:00 PM 18 mins to read

Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.

Already a subscriber?

Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.

Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

RNZ chair Brent Impey and former chief financial officer Hilary Parker; Former TVNZ political editors, from left, Linda Clark, Mark Sainsbury, Guyon Espiner, Jessica Mutch-McKay and Maiki Sherman.

An 8.46pm resignation email: documents reveal new details of RNZ CFO’s departure; Mark Sainsbury challenges TVNZ plan to scrap political editor role; Mystery ‘news site’ falls silent; Top agencies land $45m Health NZ work; the Screen and IAB awards.

New details have emerged about RNZ chief financial officer Hilary Parker’s abrupt departure seven weeks ago, including revelations she raised “differences” in the broadcaster’s accounts with the acting chief executive hours before resigning.

Documents obtained by the Herald under the Official Information Act provide new insight into what unfolded at the public broadcaster on Friday, October 2 – culminating in Parker’s resignation in an email at 8.46pm.

In a no-surprises message to government officials and Media and Communications Minister Paul Goldsmith’s office the following Monday, RNZ director of communications and engagement Kim Grade wrote “about an issue which emerged” on the previous Friday, “relating to the FY2025/26 year-end financial accounts”.

Advertise with NZME.

“That afternoon, RNZ’s chief financial officer informed the acting chief executive of differences between the previously reported position and the draft year-end accounts,” Grade wrote in the message, also released to the Herald .

“We are still working to establish the reasons for these differences.

“Early indications are that they relate mainly to the accounting treatment and timing of certain transactions.

“There is no suggestion at this stage of any financial irregularity or fraud.

“The scale, cause and year-end impact of these differences are still being confirmed through the finance, audit and annual report process.

“While we are still in the early stages of understanding the extent of these differences, we wanted to alert you early that the final position for year-end is now expected to show a larger deficit than previously forecast.”

In a covering letter to Media Insider’s OIA request, RNZ said “Hilary Parker’s resignation was received by RNZ via email at 8.46pm” on the Friday.

“It was received by acting CEO Mark Stevens and chief people officer Sarah Neilson . The resignation was accepted by Neilson at 9.29pm.”

RNZ has withheld that correspondence “to protect the privacy of natural persons”, a decision the Herald is appealing to the Ombudsman.

Stevens - filling in for Paul Thompson , who was overseas - advised RNZ board chairman Brent Impey of Parker’s resignation that Friday evening.

“Brent Impey had a conversation with RNZ director Richard Dellabarca on Saturday ... after he was informed of the resignation of the CFO the night before.

“A verbal offer was made for Mr Dellabarca to assume the role of acting chief financial officer, effective Monday 5 October.”

RNZ’s board also met on the Sunday to confirm Dellabarca’s appointment.

In her note to the minister, Grade said Dellabarca was “an experienced governance professional and executive leader with financial management expertise and is a chartered accountant”.

“Richard’s immediate priority is to work with the finance team and auditors to establish the cause and extent of the differences, complete the FY2025/26 year-end financial accounts, and confirm any implications for FY2026/27 planning.”

The documents add more detail to the timeline surrounding RNZ’s financial blowout.

The Herald revealed last week that auditors had been examining RNZ’s finances through September before raising substantive issues with Parker.

The Audit Office confirmed to the Herald that its contracted auditors from EY identified issues in an on-site audit at RNZ that month.

EY met with Parker on Tuesday, September 29.

“EY completed the substance of the audit through the month of September, their point of contact was the RNZ CFO,” an RNZ spokeswoman said last week.

“There was an audit meeting with the RNZ CFO on Tuesday, September 29, where substantive issues were raised by the audit partner EY for the first time.

“Wider RNZ management became aware of these matters on Friday, October 2. The acting chief executive informed the RNZ board chair that day.”

RNZ staff are furious and devastated about what has unfolded over the past two weeks – the announcement of an unexpected $11.8 million loss in the 2025/26 financial year and a forecast $7.8m loss this financial year.

That also came with news that RNZ would now need to cut 58 roles rather than 25-30 by next March.

Among the issues outlined in RNZ’s annual finances, $2m of revenue from the sale of land was incorrectly accounted for in the budget, personnel expenses increased by $3.2m, and operating expenses increased by $6.4m.

RNZ executives face the chop

RNZ has confirmed it will be culling its executive team as part of cost-cutting measures.

The broadcaster has an executive of eight people, arguably one or two top-heavy with a staff of just under 350 (soon to be just under 300 if RNZ’s cost-cutting plans proceed).

TVNZ, with about 520 fulltime equivalent staff, has an executive team of six.

“We have made clear in our communications with staff that the proposed reductions will be across all levels and all parts of the business,” an RNZ spokeswoman said.

“For the avoidance of doubt this does include the executive.”

Mark Sainsbury on TVNZ political editor move

Former TVNZ political editor Mark Sainsbury has urged the broadcaster to rethink its plans to scrap the role, while also revealing how much political pressure comes with the job.

Sainsbury, a New Zealand broadcasting and journalism hall-of-famer and TVNZ’s political editor from 2000-2006, said the parliamentary role was too important to lose in an age of media turmoil.

“The role of political editor has always been a crucial one for all bureaus covering parliament but even more so for TVNZ,” Sainsbury told Media Insider.

“Politicians of all hues would champion the independence of TVNZ, but behind the scenes the pressure was always on. Owned by the government, the requirement for fair independent coverage was more acutely felt than in other sectors.”

Sainsbury also revealed some of the political pressure he encountered while in the job, including an episode that almost prompted him to quit.

“I once threatened to resign and in hindsight probably should have when TVNZ caved to pressure from then chair Ross Armstrong [a National Party grandee appointed by a Labour Government] and partially upheld his complaint about a story of mine.

“I later discovered he had threatened to resign as chair if it wasn’t upheld which would have caused ructions in the Beehive. It was, I considered, a craven capitulation to political pressure.”

Media Insider revealed TVNZ’s plans this week to scrap the political editor role, as part of sweeping newsroom changes involving dozens of roles.

TVNZ has reiterated it is not losing headcount, but is not commenting on specific proposed changes or roles, while it consults staff and hears feedback.

The reorganisation is designed to meet audience demands across a 24/7 news cycle and move from what is considered a sometimes overbearing internal focus on the 6pm news bulletin.

TVNZ has been without a political editor since May, when Maiki Sherman resigned after intense media and political scrutiny following two high-profile incidents. She said her position had become “untenable”.

Sainsbury questioned whether political motives were at play in the proposal to scrap the role entirely.

“Do they have trouble finding someone to fill it? To say it’s founded on a desire to provide broader coverage on their digital platform simply doesn’t bear scrutiny.

“The role of political editor was to provide context to current political events and to lead and back a team.

“The pressures on the political bureau were constant and it often fell to the political editor to hold the line and defend its independence.

“It also required the maturity to own up when mistakes were made.

“What then do we make of the decision to abandon it?

“Many rival news organisations have a digital focus which should and often does harness the political editor to expand coverage. Why then does TVNZ see it as a some sort of handbrake?”

Sainsbury is one of many well-known broadcasters and journalists to have held the role, others have included Richard Harman , Linda Clark , Guyon Espiner , Corin Dann and Jessica Mutch-McKay .

Sainsbury said abandoning the political editor position raised questions about TVNZ’s role more generally.

“There’s no shortage of streaming services, is TVNZ then just another? Or has politics become simply too risky to cover for nervous management?

“The whole news gathering and reporting world is in turmoil; it is harder and harder to discern what is even real or fake.

“Trust in the source is paramount and the political editors role is essentially one of trust with the viewer, it’s too important we can’t afford to lose it.”

Sainsbury said his biggest fear was the move would signal a retreat from comprehensive news coverage, an assertion TVNZ hotly disputed.

“We’ve proposed changes to strengthen and enhance our news operation for the future, so we can better serve our audience with news whenever they need it, not just at set broadcast times,” a spokeswoman said earlier this week.

“We’re not looking to reduce the size of our newsroom, but some roles could evolve to support this. We’re seeking feedback so won’t be commenting on the details of the proposal.”

TVNZ reiterated its earlier comments yesterday and commented further.

“Fair, impartial and robust journalism is central to who we are, so we’re not looking to reduce the strength of our political reporting, but we may approach it differently,” the spokeswoman said.

“Our election campaign is a great example of this – and we reached one in every two New Zealanders with our coverage.

“What worked in past decades won’t necessarily work in the future.”

Analysis: The case for change

On the face of it, many of TVNZ’s plans – what we know of them, publicly, so far – make sense and arguably should have happened earlier, as the broadcaster watched audiences shift from traditional TV viewing to digital platforms.

There’s a belief in some quarters internally that TVNZ’s newsroom is still fixated on the 6pm news – one source spoke this week of examples of breaking news videos being held until the bulletin, with only screengrabs being provided to the 1News website earlier in the day.

Right now, the 1News website is a distant fourth to Stuff, NZ Herald and RNZ.

TVNZ has clearly recognised it needs to become more competitive on that front, and with news on its streaming platform TVNZ+.

Most New Zealand newsrooms have been through major transformation over the past decade and continue to do so, in response to audience behaviour.

Where once the NZ Herald newsroom, for example, was geared towards a night-time deadline for the next day’s paper, journalistic and work practices are now completely focused on digital platforms.

That’s not to say the newspaper is left behind; news editors get to curate the best of the day’s work for the next morning’s paper. And often a big exclusive can hold, to be broken on nzherald.co.nz at 5am, while simultaneously appearing on the front page of the print edition.

But it takes years to transform newsroom work practices – and it’s a Herculean human relations task in winning the hearts and minds of journalists.

Real-time data now provides incredible detail of what, when and how audiences are consuming news.

It’s critical journalists see that for themselves – in the case of TVNZ, for example, why a video should be published on 1News’ website and TVNZ+ at, say, noon, rather than 6pm.

They also need to be properly briefed on the rationale for change.

As part of the proposals, TVNZ appears keen to break down silos within its newsroom – for instance, it’s also planning to ditch the Indepth team, which was established after the demise of Fair Go and Sunday in 2024.

The Indepth team features some of TVNZ’s best journalists, but as other news organisations have found, specialist investigative teams can sometimes lead to an environment of envy, or a “them and us” split.

By looking to redraw job descriptions, TVNZ is likely wanting to create a more egalitarian news operation where junior and mid-grade reporters have the same opportunities to work on bigger stories.

As for the political editorship, TVNZ bosses must have known its plan to scrap the role would likely be the most contentious and debated proposal. Multiple sources have been astounded by the proposal.

The broadcaster can rightly point to its recent general election coverage, which showed it could produce strong political coverage without somebody formally occupying the political editor’s chair.

Jack Tame led TVNZ’s poll coverage with authority, clarity and verve while political reporters Benedict Collins , Sophie Trigger and Tom Day did a superb job, in the circumstances, of covering myriad political issues.

TVNZ’s political editor role has become one of the most scrutinised and criticised roles in New Zealand journalism. Spreading its responsibilities may also dissipate some of the public and political pressure that comes with the job.

I have no doubt that if the right person with the attributes, experience and skills did come along – someone like Tame but, sadly, he’s Auckland-based and unavailable – TVNZ would rethink the proposal.

But for now it’s willing to shake things up.

Sport Nation staff face the axe

A number of staff at radio network Sport Nation are losing their jobs and facing an uncertain future as MediaWorks’ Australian owner prepares to take over operating the loss-making station.

Some workers say they were given notice of their redundancies today while other contractors were alerted earlier this week that their arrangements with Entain would end in December.

Sources earlier told Media Insider that Sport Nation, which holds radio and audio commentary rights to a portfolio of sport and is home to well-known hosts including Scotty Stevenson , Israel Dagg , Tony Johnson , Mark Stafford , Kyle Mills and Guy Heveldt , had been losing millions.

MediaWorks and SEG confirmed on Friday morning the Herald’s earlier reporting that they were taking over operating Sport Nation from December 1 and that it would be broadcast on an Auckland frequency next year.

Details of that frequency have not been confirmed.

Entain did not refer to the redundancies or financial losses in the joint public relations statement today, and it has not responded to specific questions.

In the statement, Entain New Zealand managing director Chris Haigh said the new agreement represented “an exciting opportunity to build on Sport Nation’s established presence and strengthen its connection with sports and racing audiences”.

Sports Entertainment Group chief executive Craig Hutchison said he was delighted to welcome Sport Nation back into the fold - his firm used to own the station.

“We’ve enjoyed a long-term relationship with Entain in New Zealand and are excited to shape the next era of Sport Nation.”

Mystery ‘news site’ goes quiet after scrutiny

A curious media story has been unfolding in Southland, where journalist Logan Savory has been trying to establish who is behind a new website called the Invercargill Herald .

Savory, a respected local journalist who publishes his own website and newsletter, the Southland Tribune , says he became suspicious when the new platform started taking content from other news sites, including his own, about two weeks ago.

“It was making slight changes to Tribune articles, most likely via AI, then adding a small amount of attribution, and republishing those Tribune stories as their own,” Savory wrote this week.

That led to inquiries and a story about who was behind it.

Under the headline, “A new ‘news site’, borrowed stories and a mystery editor”, Savory outlined his attempts to find ‘Damian Bell’ , who is listed as editor of the Invercargill Herald .

He hasn’t been able to find anyone with that name operating in the region, and there ha s been no other contact from anyone representing the Invercargill Herald .

He has his suspicions about who’s behind the site.

“I think it’s a case of a young tech whizz thinking he could start up this AI-generated news site and no one would ask any questions,” Savory told Media Insider.

“The good thing that has come out of it, I think, is that it seems to have opened the eyes of a few people around taking a website that mimics a local news site as legitimate media without knowing who is behind it, and where the editorial accountability might be.”

Savory says the Invercargill Herald website and its Facebook page have stopped publishing content since his story appeared.

Savory’s own site, meanwhile, has become a consistently strong news provider over the past three years, but he was candid in his story this week that it might not survive longer term.