Can we have an uncomfortable Friday afternoon conversation about the economy?

See, there's a phrase we're hearing more and more, as the Reserve Bank grapples with Australia's stubborn inflation problem.

The RBA, we're warned, could "tip Australia into recession".

It's usually delivered with the sort of gravity reserved for an impending natural disaster.

And fair enough, too.

Recessions are bad. Really bad.

People lose their jobs. Businesses close. Families struggle to pay their bills. Some people who lose their jobs won't find another for months, or even years. They could lose homes, and relationships, and that can tragically contribute to people taking their own lives.

(If you or someone you know is struggling, there are some resources mentioned at the end of this article. Please use them, if you need to. We want you here.)

And the consequences can last well beyond the recession itself.

So I'm certainly not going to suggest we should welcome one.

But I do want to ask a potentially uncomfortable question.

What if avoiding a recession isn't always the best outcome?

Or, put differently, what if the price of avoiding a recession is sometimes greater than the cost of having one?

Before you accuse me of having lost my marbles, hear me out.

Because I think there's an important economic conversation we're not really having.

And it matters enormously for the decisions facing the Reserve Bank and the Governments (Federal and State) right now.

Let's rewind: Australia has, by conventional measures, avoided a recession since the COVID-induced downturn of 2020.

That's a good thing, right?

But let's consider what else has happened.

Consumer prices have risen by roughly a quarter since 2020. Not 25% a year, thankfully, but cumulatively. Something that cost $100 back then now costs roughly $125, on average.

Meanwhile, real wages, which measure what our pay packets can actually buy, fell sharply as inflation outpaced wage increases. There's been some recovery, but many Australians are still feeling the consequences.

And while the overall economy has continued growing, GDP per capita has told a rather different story.

For much of the past few years, economic output per Australian has been falling or barely growing.

In other words, we've avoided the 'technical definition' of a recession while experiencing something that, for many households, hasn't felt much like economic prosperity.

Now, I'm not suggesting those outcomes were inevitable, or that a recession would necessarily have been preferable.

But consider a thought experiment.

What if, instead of the economic experience we've actually had, Australia had endured a relatively short recession, followed by a quicker return to low inflation and stronger growth in real wages?

Would we have been better off?

We can't rerun history, unfortunately. The economy doesn't come with a rewind button and a Choose Your Own Adventure book.

And a recession might have brought its own lasting damage.

But here's the point: we shouldn't simply assume that avoiding recession was necessarily the better outcome.

Because the alternative hasn't exactly been painless.

Does that still sound a bit weird? I assume so – because we've been told over and over again that a recession is the worst thing that could happen.

Part of the problem, I reckon, is that the costs of recession are relatively obvious.

When someone loses their job, the consequences can be immediate and devastating.

When a business closes, we can see the empty store, the unemployed workers and the financial losses.

Those are real people, experiencing real hardship. They get counted, reported and – let's be honest, here – used as fodder to get clicks and make overtly selfish political arguments.

And I want to be very clear: their suffering should never be dismissed as a statistical inconvenience or an acceptable sacrifice for some theoretical economic benefit.

But inflation causes hardship, too.

It eats away at purchasing power. It makes it harder for all families to afford groceries, housing, insurance and other essentials.

It punishes people whose incomes don't keep pace, particularly those with limited financial resources.

It diminishes the value of cash.

And when inflation persists, those costs compound over time.

Importantly, getting inflation back down to 2% or 3% doesn't mean prices return to where they were.

It means they're increasing more slowly, from an already higher base.

That lost purchasing power doesn't simply reappear. It's gone. For good.

So here's the uncomfortable reality.

When policymakers decide how hard to fight inflation, they're making choices that affect millions of Australians, often in very different ways.

Higher interest rates may mean weaker spending, struggling businesses and higher unemployment.

But leaving inflation elevated can mean years of diminished purchasing power and pressure on living standards across the country.

And neither is costless.

But what about the longer term?

That's another dimension to this debate that I think deserves more attention – and gets very little.

Economic decisions don't just affect the next few months or quarters.

They can shape a country's prosperity for decades.

Consider the early 1980s.

In the United States, Federal Reserve chairman Paul Volcker pursued extraordinarily tough monetary policy to defeat the entrenched inflation of the 1970s.

The result was a brutal recession. Unemployment climbed to almost 11%.

Australia experienced a painful recession around the same period, with tighter monetary policy, international weakness and drought all playing their part.

The human costs were enormous.

But there's also a strong argument that restoring price stability helped, in part at least, lay the foundations for the more prosperous decades that followed.

Not by itself, of course. Economic reforms, technological progress, productivity improvements and plenty of other factors mattered enormously.

And we shouldn't pretend the recovery was equally beneficial to everyone.

Still, the example raises an important possibility.

Sometimes accepting economic pain today can help create better conditions for tomorrow.

Equally, recessions can permanently damage businesses, careers, skills and investment, leaving an economy poorer than it might otherwise have been.

That's the problem: the consequences flow both ways.

And we can't know in advance, with any certainty, precisely how those consequences will unfold.

Which brings us back to Australia in 2026.

The RBA recently lifted interest rates again, taking the cash rate to 4.85%, as inflation remains stubbornly above its target.

And the warnings are familiar.

Keep raising rates, we're told, and the RBA risks tipping Australia into recession.

They're right. It does.

And that risk should be taken very seriously.

But what about the risk of not raising rates enough?

What about the possibility that inflation stays higher for longer, further eroding purchasing power and potentially becoming harder to control?

What if avoiding a recession today simply makes the eventual economic adjustment more painful?

Of course, the reverse could also be true.

What if the RBA raises rates too far, causes unnecessary unemployment and damages an economy that might otherwise have returned to low inflation without a recession?

These aren't rhetorical questions with obvious answers.

(Importantly, don't listen to anyone who takes either side and refuses to admit the chance they're wrong. They're either self-interested, ideologues or have a barrow to push!)

These are genuinely difficult choices monetary and fiscal policymakers face.

And there's no simple equation that tells us exactly how much inflation we should tolerate to protect employment, or how much unemployment we should risk to restore price stability. (Oh, there are economic models, and they're actually useful – they just don't include the human costs of both unemployment and inflation, so they're incomplete.)

Nor can the RBA precisely dial up a little more unemployment in exchange for a little less inflation. The economy is considerably messier than that.

But those trade-offs are real, even when we prefer not to acknowledge them.

At some point, policymakers must consider how much economic pain the nation should collectively bear to reduce the risk of unemployment.

And, just as importantly, how much unemployment and lost economic activity we're prepared to risk to reduce inflation.

That's not about pitting employed Australians against unemployed Australians, or suggesting the hardship of either group matters less.

It's about recognising that national economic policy necessarily involves weighing competing costs, benefits and risks.

And those judgements affect not only our prosperity today, but potentially our prosperity for many years to come.

So, should the RBA risk a recession to bring inflation down?

I don't know. But maybe. We shouldn't rule it out.

Perhaps we can get inflation under control without a recession. I'd love to hope so.

Perhaps a recession would be an unnecessarily high price to pay.

Or perhaps trying too hard to avoid one would ultimately leave us worse off.

So far, inflation has been 25% over the past half-decade or so, and we still have 4.9% unemployment! I'm not saying we've got it wrong, but I think it's hard to suggest this is the least-worst outcome, so far, overall.

What I do know is that we shouldn't treat avoiding a recession as an objective to be pursued at any cost.

Because recessions aren't the only things that cause economic hardship.

And sometimes the most important question isn't whether a particular outcome is bad.

It's whether the alternatives might be worse.

If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, help is available.

Lifeline: Call 13 11 14, text 0477 13 11 14, or chat online

Beyond Blue: Call 1300 22 4636 or chat online

Emergency: Call 000 if someone is in immediate danger.

Wondering where to invest $1,000 right now?

When investing expert Scott Phillips has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Motley Fool Share Advisor newsletter he has run for over ten years has provided thousands of paying members with stock picks that have doubled, tripled or even more.*

Scott just revealed what he believes could be the 'five best ASX stocks' for investors to buy right now. We believe these stocks are trading at attractive prices and Scott thinks they could be great buys right now…

* Returns as of 6 March 2025

CBA shares back on top of the ASX 200 as BHP dives 13% this week

BHP share price drops 13% to seven-month low in just 1 week. Do experts say buy?

5 ASX 200 shares experts recommend we buy amid the market carnage this week

Commonwealth Bank is selling Count stock. Should you buy it?

Buy, hold, sell: Hub24, Reece, Ramsay Healthcare shares

Motley Fool contributor Scott Phillips has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia’s parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy . This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.