Following the inquest, Letterkenny University Hospital (LUH) apologised to the family of Nellie Mhic Niallais, from Doirí Beaga in Co Donegal, who died on 20 February 2023.
LUH expressed sincere condolences and said that it regretted the tragic loss and deep distress experienced by the MacNiallais family.
The hospital apologised "unreservedly that the standard of care delivered to Nellie during her admission", adding that it "fell below an acceptable standard".
Donegal Coroner's Court heard this was "a tragic case", and that Ms Mhic Niallais lived independently, at home, prior to her admission on 9 February 2023.
The inquest was told that Ms Mhic Niallais was a much-loved member of her family, a devoted sister, mother and grandmother, who lived a full life.
Her family, who praised many of the hospital staff, believed that she had a lot left to live and went into hospital with a simple ailment and never came home, the inquest heard.
Doireann O'Mahoney BL, instructed by Callan Tansey Solicitors, representing the Mac Niallais family, said that "no one intended" for Ms Mhic Niallais to lose her life, but it happened on foot of the care plan she received.
Treatment of Nellie Mhic Niallais
Coroner Dr Denis McCauley said that Ms Mhic Niallais was admitted to LUH with septic arthritis on 9 February.
She was initially treated by an aspiration of her knee joint on 10 February and given an antibiotic when test results were returned on 12 February.
Ms Mhic Niallais was found to have a kidney infection and her condition worsened around 15 February when her blood pressure dropped below 20% of her admission reading.
Dr McCauley noted an occasion when an escalation of treatment did not take place, when there was "a unique drop in blood pressure".
He noted other occasions where a need for an escalation of treatment was recognised in the hospital and this did not occur.
Dr McCauley also alluded to blood tests that were ordered on Friday 17 February, due to be taken on Saturday 18 February, that "demonstrated an alarming morbidity".
The results of these blood tests were not noted, so medical staff were not aware of these results, the inquest heard.
Dr McCauley said that Ms Mhic Niallais’ condition further deteriorated on the weekend of 18 and 19 February, noting appropriate escalation was not followed.
She developed an acute upper gastrointestinal haemorrhage on 20 February.
Her acute kidney injury further worsened and she went from sepsis into significant clinical septic shock before she had a cardiac event, the inquest heard.
Dr McCauley said that Ms McNelis died after her heart stopped due to severe septic shock and acute kidney failure.
He returned a verdict of death by medical misadventure.
The cause of death was acute coronary insufficiency, secondary to multi-organ failure, septic shock, acute kidney injury and coronary atherosclerosis.
The inquest was told that Ms Mhic Niallais, who had underlying medical conditions, had a kidney function appropriate to a lady of her age when she was admitted.
Her daughter, Gráinne Nic Niallais, said she cannot understand why she was not contacted until 12.45pm on 20 February 2023, when told septic signs were flagged hours earlier.
The inquest heard that Gráinne Nic Niallais, who called her mother every morning, contacted her twice on the morning of Monday 20 February 2023 but received no answer.
Later that morning, she received three phone calls from the hospital, the first one asking her to come immediately and two more following up.
Ms Mhic Niallais was admitted to ICU at 1pm that day. She died that night.
'The centre of a close family'
Following the inquest, Gráinne Nic Niallais said that it had been "extremely difficult to hear about the lack of care and attention" her mother received in her final days.
While acknowledging the hospital’s apology, Ms Nic Niallais said she hoped the failings highlighted through the inquest would be taken seriously and that lessons would be learned.
"My mother, Nellie, was so much more than a hospital patient. She was a much-loved mother, grandmother, sister, aunt and friend and the centre of a close family.
"Her loss has left a lasting sadness in all our lives. It has been heartbreaking to learn that my mother did not receive the standard of care she deserved.
"No family should have to hear that their loved one was let down in this way. She deserved dignity, compassion, attention and proper care - every patient deserves that," she said.
"While I acknowledge the HSE’s apology, no words can undo what happened or bring my mother back.
"I sincerely hope the failings highlighted through this inquest will be taken seriously, that lessons will be learned and meaningful changes will follow so that other families do not have to experience something similar.
Ms Nic Niallais said she wishes for her mother to be remembered as the wonderful person that she was and not simply, "for the circumstances surrounding her death".
Coroner’s recommendations
The coroner issued a number of recommendations at the conclusion of the inquest, concerning the provision of care at Letterkenny University Hospital.
Dr McCauley applauded a HSE statement, which detailed a greater emphasis on the training and audit of the screening for sepsis, since the death of Ms Mhic Niallais.
He also recognised the employment of advanced nurse practitioners (ANP) with specialist training in the recognition of sepsis, who can be consulted for an opinion.
Dr McCauley said there is an "obvious deficit" that these nurses in Letterkenny are only employed on a Monday to Friday from 9am to 5pm.
He commended the formation of an emergency response team in LUH, which is called for an acutely ill patient who is suffering from potential septic shock.
He recommended that drug names be written on hospital records in the generic form, so that the treating doctor is fully aware of the treatment that the patient is on.
Finally, Dr McCauley said responsibility for reviewing and actioning blood tests ordered by a treating team, not on call over a weekend, should be handed over to working staff.




