Fifth Melbourne Cup revealed as stolen after 'staggering' Spring Racing Carnival heists

By crime reporter Olivia Jenkins

Topic: Horse Racing

Posted Fri 20 Nov 2026 at 4:18pm Fri 20 Nov 2026 at 4:18pm Fri 20 Nov 2026 at 4:18pm

The ABC can reveal a fifth Melbourne Cup was stolen from Flemington Racecourse several years before the series of heists during this year's Spring Racing Carnival.

Earlier this month, the 1948 Caulfield Cup was stolen from Caulfield Racecourse and later Makybe Diva's three Melbourne Cups were taken from Flemington.

Two men have been charged over the thefts, and during a court appearance this week it emerged a fourth replica cup had been stolen during the carnival.

Six Melbourne and Caulfield cups are missing, it can be revealed, as the Victoria Racing Club (VRC) comes under fire by racing insiders over cup carnival security measures.

The ABC can reveal that in addition to four Melbourne Cups and one Caulfield Cup stolen in the recent heists during the peak of this year's racing carnival, the 1973 Melbourne Cup, which was stolen from Flemington several years ago, has never been found.

The late jockey Frank Reys became the first Indigenous jockey to win the historic race with Australian thoroughbred gelding Gala Supreme.

Years after Reys' death from cancer in 1984, his family donated the cup to the VRC.

The ABC understands it was stolen from its display near the exclusive Committee Room at Flemington Racecourse, but the exact date of the theft remains unclear.

The theft was reported to police but the cup was never recovered.

Darren Hutchins, whose grandfather trained winning runner Gala Supreme, told the ABC it was "pretty disappointing" that five additional cups had been stolen years after the one belonging to his grandfather's winner had also been swiped.

"To have one disappear is horrific … but to have four more disappear, where's the accountability around this?" he said.

"I just think it's horrendous that this could be allowed to happen.

"It seems like it was pretty easy to access them and get away with it.

"I just find it staggering that the level of security was as lax as it must've been."

It comes after police charged two men , Sama Mirzaagha and Chrysovalandis Tassakos, over the recent Flemington and Caulfield heists.

The 1948 Caulfield Cup won by Red Fury was stolen from Caulfield Racecourse between November 4 and November 11, along with bottles of wine and other "low-value" items.

The ABC understands the Caulfield Cup has been melted down; with fears the stolen Melbourne Cups have also suffered the same fate.

A replica Melbourne Cup was allegedly stolen from Flemington on November 12.

Four days later, alleged thieves dressed as tradies swiped legendary Makybe Diva's three consecutive Melbourne Cups worth $3 million.

Call to replace stolen Makybe Diva cups

Mr Hutchins called on the VRC to disclose the level of security they had employed to guard the stolen cups, in addition to CCTV and alarms that were triggered during the alleged robberies at Flemington.

"Transparency's key … I don't think they have anything to hide," he said.

"I think they'd be better off coming out and saying what's happened," he said.

"Just be up-front and tell people exactly what's gone on."

Mr Hutchins also called on the VRC to remake Makybe Diva's cups if the originals were permanently lost or melted down, because owner Tony Santic had loaned the trophies to them during this year's cup carnival.

"If they don't find these within a timely manner, then replace them … with proper models, not duped up dummies," he said.

"A replacement's the least they could do."

Charged with burglary, theft, and dealing with property suspected of being the proceeds of crime over the Flemington robberies, Mr Mirzaagha was remanded following a brief magistrates court hearing yesterday.

Mr Tassakos was charged over the alleged thefts at both venues and was bailed.

The pair will return to court in February.

Mr Hutchins said he hoped the recent spate of alleged thefts would reignite the search for the 1973 Melbourne Cup.

"I hope it hasn't been melted because they're just irreplaceable items,"

The VRC declined to comment.

X (formerly Twitter)

See more ABC coverage in your search results

Make ABC a preferred source in Google

Xi Jinping declares 'complete turnaround' in China's relations with Australia