Sign of the Times: City of Joondalup reveals bill spent on election sign complaints

Liam Murphy Northern Suburbs Weekly

19 November 2026, 2:00am

Managing election sign complaints cost City of Joondalup ratepayers an estimated $50,900 in staff time last year.

The city says it received 240 complaints during the 2025 Federal, State and local government elections, requiring 1018 hours of staff time to investigate and respond.

The time-consuming task of policing the signs had prompted the city to propose a major shake-up of its election signage rules.

However, the proposal was rejected in a tied vote at this week’s council meeting after mayor Daniel Kingston put forward an alternative recommendation to retain the existing restrictions, contrary to the city’s advice.

He used his casting vote to secure its passage, preserving the five-sign-per-suburb limit

The changes would have given candidates free rein over the number of signs they could display and allowed them to erect them in suburbs outside their electorate.

Under the existing rules, candidates are limited to five signs per suburb and can display them only in suburbs in their nominated electorate.

The proposed changes would have also doubled the permitted display period from 30 to 60 days before an election.

Mr Kingston said he believed removing the cap would be problematic and it could allow candidates to “buy elections” by putting out as many signs as possible.

“Just five per suburb in the thoroughfares for the areas in which somebody is running before election, I think that’s suitable,” Mr Kingston said.

“I don’t think it’s excessive for our community. I think if we had unlimited signage, I think it would become excessive.

“I think there are ways in which this can be managed responsibly … But also, I think not enforcing the rules is also a sign of a problem.”

Mr Kingston said he had never had one of his own signs impounded for breaching the rules and considered candidates who flouted the restrictions to be seeking an unfair advantage.

“I think if you’re breaching a rule, I think it’s a form of cheating,” he said.

“I think you’re trying to cheat to win. So if you’re that kind of person, I think you should be fined, and I think the public should see that.”

City of Joondalup officers had recommended the changes because complaints consumed “significant resources” and enforcement was “challenging and resource intensive”.

“It is clear from the recent experiences around election signage that there is a significant number of complaints around election signs, which ultimately needs to be investigated on balance with other enforcement activities the city is required to undertake at the time,” the officers said in a report.

“The revised standards for the City of Joondalup are considered suitable to gain the balance between election activity, road safety concerns, administrative resourcing and enforcement capability.”

The complaints came from candidates, community members and elected members, and related to the placement and number of election signs, as well as how they were managed.

The most costly election to manage was last year’s October local government election, which attracted 140 signage complaints and an estimated $19,250 in staff costs.

Both the 2025 State and Federal elections attracted 50 signage complaints each, with an estimated $15,825 in staff costs apiece.

The new rules would have also allowed the city to remove and impound election signs that are not taken down within seven days of polling day.

Unlike Joondalup, candidates in neighbouring Stirling, Swan and Wanneroo can put up election signs without being subject to a limit.

Stirling and Swan also allow signs to be displayed for up to 60 days before an election, while Wanneroo only permits a 28-day display period.

In addition to the five-sign-per-suburb limit, election signs in the City of Joondalup are restricted to 0.75sqm in area and must comply with road safety requirements.

Election signs were previously not permitted on road verges and thoroughfares, but the city changed its position ahead of the 2019 local government elections after receiving legal advice on the implied freedom of political communication afforded under the Australian Constitution.

Cr Rebecca Pizzey was one of six councillors who voted against the mayor’s alternative recommendation, stating her opposition was primarily on legal grounds.

“Election signs are not one of the things I like. They’re probably one of the things I like least about running for office. They’re a chore to put up, look after. They get stolen and defaced,” Cr Pizzey said.

“Many residents find them an eyesore, but they’re a necessary evil of standing for election.

“The High Court has recognised implied freedom of political communication in the Constitution. It is an impersonal right, but it does limit what governments, including local governments, can do to restrict political communication.

“Election signs sit right at the centre of that freedom. Any rule that limits them has to have a legitimate purpose and has to be a proportionate way of achieving it.”