Jury retires in marathon parental overdose murder trial

19 November 2026, 11:36am

The jury in the marathon trial of a woman accused of murdering her elderly parents with insulin has retired to consider its verdicts.

Brenda and Lynton Anderson were both aged 94 when they died in March 2022 and May 2023 respectively.

Each had faced declining health and the prospect of being moved into aged care but prosecutors allege their daughter Raelene Polymiaidis injected both her parents with insulin.

Polymiadis, 65 and a type 1 diabetic, has pleaded not guilty to two counts of murder.

The 12-person jury in the South Australian Supreme Court trial retired to consider its verdict at 1.16pm on Thursday.

A key element of the case against Polymiadis has been recordings from a police listening device.

She was recorded alone in her car praying to God on two occasions, allegedly confessing that she had killed her parents.

The marathon trial, which began on June 15, has heard evidence from family members, hospital staff, detectives and expert medical evidence about insulin and hypoglycemia.

It was scheduled to run for three months but is now in its sixth month.

Prosecutor Michael Foundas has told the jury that one potential motive for Polymiadis is perhaps some misplaced idea that killing her parents would spare them from a nursing home.

After Mrs Anderson had a fall in February 2022, she was admitted to Noarlunga Hospital with a fractured vertebra, complicated by pneumonia and another fall.

After Polymiadis visited her mother on March 12, nursing staff found Mrs Anderson largely unresponsive.

The prosecution alleges Polymiadis twice administered insulin to her mother - on March 12 and between March 13 and 15.

"It was the insulin that killed her," Mr Foundas said.

Mr Anderson continued to live at home after his wife's death but became more frail and his four children began staying there at night on a shift basis.

Polymiadis left the house on April 30, 2023, after staying with her father for the weekend.

Two hours later, a carer found Mr Anderson unconscious. He died on May 1 as a result of insulin toxicity.

On June 20, 2023 - the same day Polymiadis was interviewed by Major Crime detectives - she bared her soul in a clear and unambiguous confession captured on police listening devices, Mr Foundas said.

"Please, Lord, you know, yes, I have sinned. I have. Thou shall not kill", Polymiadis says in the recording.

"I have sinned twice in my life, and I hate it, but I also know ... your blessing, Lord, that they did not want to go to a nursing home, that was their wish."

Defence counsel Marie Shaw KC challenged the prosecution's interpretation of the recordings.

"Was my client admitting she was responsible for this, or was she telling her God that she felt responsible for their deaths?" Ms Shaw said.

"Because if they died of insulin administration, they must have accessed her insulin."

The defence also challenged the prosecution's reliance on blood samples and expert opinions, questioning their accuracy and potential contamination.