English greats add weight to Cummins pile-on
Justin Chadwick AAP
19 November 2026, 12:18pm
England's cricket royalty have piled on to Australia's sandpapergate "crisis", with the future of Test skipper Pat Cummins put under the biggest blowtorch.
Cameron Bancroft's 4000-word statement on Wednesday left world cricket in a spin and former England captains Michael Vaughan, Alastair Cook, Michael Atherton and Nasser Hussain were quick to rip in.
Cummins' insistence he knew nothing of the plot to tamper with the ball during the 2018 tour of South Africa flies in the face of Bancroft's accusation the entire team knew.
"He (Bancroft) finally unburdened himself after eight years of mental torture, and in doing so placed CA (Cricket Australia) and Pat Cummins' captaincy in crisis," Atherton wrote.
Hussain said Cummins was now in a "very difficult position".
"Finally, the truth is coming out. It's often not the crime, it's the cover-up that gets you," Hussain told Sky Sports.
"It looks like the truth is coming out from within that dressing room, and I wouldn't be surprised if others came out."
When asked if Cummins' position as captain was now untenable, Hussain replied: "Well, he's got some explaining to do because he was so strong ... in his denial of what Usman Khawaja wrote in that book about the sandpaper scandal.
"Bancroft said himself that he felt betrayed and angry and alone after that (Cummins) press conference.
"If you're going to make that press conference 68 minutes, you better make sure everything you say is 100 per cent spot on."
Hussain said one of the most damning accusations from Bancroft was that even the Australian media manager walked out on a team meeting in 2018 when the plot to tamper with the ball was being discussed.
"How does the media manager know what's going on, but a bowling unit doesn't?" Hussain pondered.
"It would be the first time a bowling unit doesn't know what's happening to a cricket ball."
Vaughan, who was England's Test captain from 2003 to 2008, said the claim that only Steve Smith, David Warner and Bancroft were aware of the tampering plot "never sat pretty" with him.
"Pat Cummins now has a big decision to make," Vaughan told BBC Sport.
"There was no way in a million years that a team wouldn't know that it was going on."
Cook, who captained England in 59 Tests before stepping aside as skipper in 2017, said the open forum announced by Cricket Australia is now irrelevant in the wake of Bancroft's stunning claims.
"The level of detail he has gone into ... and what he has said is really blowing everything open," Cook said.
"We have not heard the end of it. It is all coming out."


