Duo allegedly observed victim, plotted drive-by murder
19 November 2026, 2:20pm
For seven minutes, Kwar Ater's accused killers sat and watched him socialising with his friends as they allegedly plotted his murder.
At 3.43am on September 7, 2025, a black Mercedes pulled up alongside the group on Elizabeth Street in Melbourne's CBD.
A single gunshot rang out from the passenger side of the car and Mr Ater dropped to the ground.
Moses Laula and Ater Koth on Thursday faced a jury trial in the Victorian Supreme Court, charged with murder and murder by complicity, respectively.
Both have pleaded not guilty.
The 26-year-old victim had been staying with his girlfriend in an apartment on Elizabeth Street booked for a friend's birthday, when he went downstairs to get something from a friend.
Observing Mr Ater and his friends from inside their car parked further down on the opposite side of the street, the alleged murderers "hatched a plan", prosecutor Daniel Porceddu told jurors in his opening address.
"The seven minutes, on the prosecution's case, gave Koth and Laula an opportunity to work at how they would drive past and shoot Mr Ater," he said.
The car then drove past the victim and made a U-turn at an intersection to return on the same side of the road.
It then drove up slowly to parallel with Mr Ater was standing, without coming to a complete stop.
After the gunshot was fired, the car sped off, the jury was told.
Mr Ater was hit in the chest and was rushed to hospital but died from a haemorrhage.
The Crown alleged Koth was the driver and Laula was sitting in the front passenger seat from where the fatal shot was fired.
Jurors were told they could infer a murder agreement was reached from the way the car was driven, how it positioned itself during the shooting, the speed it travelled and how it sped off afterwards.
Koth played a critical and active role in the killing of Mr Ater and had an important task of positioning the car in order for Laula to get a clear shot, Mr Porceddu alleged.
The jury was shown CCTV footage allegedly showing the pair's movements and the Mercedes being driven in different locations leading up to the shooting.
The car Koth had hired was allegedly later found with a door ajar in a street nearly 30 kilometres away, in Dandenong North.
Koth's barrister Adam Chernok said his client had neither intentionally assisted, encouraged or commissioned, nor had he intentionally entered into an agreement, arrangement, or understanding to commit the alleged murder.
Barrister Dan Sala, representing Laula, urged the jury to consider whether they can be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that his client was the person who delivered the fatal shot.
"There is no footage, no picture and no witness who will say that at the moment (Mr Ater) was shot, that (Laula) had the gun in his hand," he said.
The trial continues.



