Tom Keating

Victoria's hospital promises treat the queues, not the causes

Labor and the Coalition promise to halve surgery waiting lists, but neither explains how they’ll staff extra operations or relieve blocked hospital beds. The deeper problems remain largely untouched.

A transit lounge is a room in which hospital patients wait to leave. They have been discharged, their medication is packed, and they are waiting for a relative, a taxi or a bed somewhere else. Moving them from the ward into a lounge frees the bed an hour or two earlier. Jess Wilson has promised $99 million for up to ten new or expanded lounges if the Coalition wins on 28 November.

It is the most revealing commitment of the Victorian campaign, because it concedes what the rest of the campaign avoids. The problem in our hospitals is less the number of people arriving than the difficulty of getting anyone out.

The campaign has otherwise been fought over the queue. At Labor’s launch on Sunday Ben Carroll promised $1.17 billion for 100,000 extra planned operations in public hospitals, enough, he says, to halve the waiting list, and $195 million for half a million more specialist appointments. That follows $1.5 billion to expand 12 emergency departments, and free walk-in dental clinics, now doubled to 20 for the same $230 million. Labor has added free abortion care, an Aboriginal healing centre and stronger nurse-to-patient ratios.

The Coalition’s flagship, announced in October, is $1.27 billion to halve the same list by buying operations from private hospitals. Beside the transit lounges sit a $40 million incentive scheme for regional health workers, a payroll tax exemption for general practices, and hospital builds at Wonthaggi and Drouin East. The Coalition has matched Labor on abortion and patient travel.

The Greens offer universal free dental care, restoration of VicHealth, fixed shares of the health budget for prevention and community health, and state-run bulk-billing GP clinics. One Nation, polling above 20 per cent, has refused to release costings and has a health policy that fits on the back of a candidate’s leaflet.

Those of us who worked in Victorian health administration in the 1990s will recognise both surgery plans. Victorian public hospitals have long been budget sector entities, owned by the state and governed by boards. Casemix funding, introduced by the Kennett government in July 1993, left that arrangement in place and changed the relationship within it. The department became a purchaser, buying specified volumes of activity from hospitals at a price for each episode of care; the hospitals became providers. Stephen Duckett led its design, and as a means of cost containment it worked: throughput rose and costs fell.

Purchasing has a place. It is good at buying more of a defined product. It is poor at the work that falls between products: discharge planning, the patient with four conditions, the frail man who cannot go home and has nowhere else to go.

Labor’s plan is casemix purchasing in its plainest form, more money for more episodes in public hospitals. The Coalition’s extends the same logic to the private sector, and Victoria has tried that. Labor’s own COVID Catch-up Plan set out to buy 51,200 extra public admissions a year from private hospitals. The Auditor-General reported in August 2025 that the state delivered 209,925 planned surgeries in 2023–24 against a target of 240,000. About two-thirds of the shortfall came from public surgery in private hospitals that did not eventuate, and the program ended $356.4 million under budget. The money was there. The anaesthetists were not.

The Coalition’s $1.27 billion happens to match, to the dollar, the Queensland government’s allocation to Surgery Connect. Borrowing a number suggests the work of fitting it to Victoria has not been done. Matthew Guy promised to halve the list in 2022. Halving is becoming a Victorian election rite.

Labor’s route is cheaper and closer to sense. The new Footscray Hospital opened in February with 16 operating theatres, some still not in use, and in other public hospitals theatre sessions sit idle for want of operating funds. Labor has not said whether its money will open them. Either way it meets the same wall as the Coalition: neither party has said where the staff for 100,000 extra operations will come from, or when. And Labor’s half a million specialist appointments will find patients who need surgery and add them to the list it promises to halve. That is good medicine and poor arithmetic.

Labor’s emergency plan has a different fault. It enlarges the front of the hospital and leaves the back unchanged. Emergency departments fill because admitted patients wait for ward beds, and ward beds fill because patients wait for rehabilitation, residential aged care or an NDIS placement. A bigger emergency department, without beds and services behind it, is a bigger waiting room. AMA/ASMOF Victoria welcomed the money and said, politely, that emergency departments do not operate in isolation. They were right.

The dental clinics are a real departure from the residual, card-holder model that has long governed public dentistry. Doubling their number without adding a dollar is a different kind of departure. The Greens’ charge that Labor has run down the existing public clinics for 12 years needs an answer before the new ones open.

What neither major party offers is an account of how the system is to be governed. Most Victorian health services ran operating deficits in 2023–24. The government responded with more money, firmer budgets imposed under the Health Services Act, and 12 local health networks whose authority remains uncertain. A Coalition government committed to large savings would inherit them. It has not said what it would do with them.

Nor has any party addressed the alternatives to admitted care that health services have been building: hospital in the home, care supported by remote monitoring, and virtual wards using digital health. Labor’s May budget put $130.3 million into its Better at Home program and then left it out of the campaign. The surest way to relieve an emergency department is to keep people out of hospital beds they do not need. A campaign conducted in beds and operations has no language for that.

Then there is VicHealth. In December 2025 Labor abolished the world’s first health promotion foundation, created in 1987 with a tobacco levy. A state that spent four decades boasting of VicHealth disposed of it in a cost-cutting round. The Greens would restore it. The major parties prefer to discuss queues. A queue is visible, and its shortening can be announced at a campaign launch. A prevented illness cannot be photographed.

Is there a party that wishes to govern the health system rather than purchase from it? On the evidence of this campaign, the answer is no. Labor offers more activity, in theatres, clinics and emergency departments, from a government that has just dismantled its own prevention agency. The Coalition offers to buy surgery from a private sector that declined the last offer, and a lounge for those waiting to leave. The Greens have the best diagnosis and will not be asked to deliver it.

The transit lounge is a sensible idea, and small. It accepts that the hospital cannot discharge patients fast enough and offers them a chair while they wait. Royal Melbourne, Footscray, Geelong, Latrobe Regional and Goulburn Valley Health already have one.

The views expressed in this article may or may not reflect those of P&I.