Politics Members only

OPINION: Le Pen's budget plans for France are a swindle

John Lichfield - news@thelocal.fr

Published: 18 Nov, 2026 CET. Updated: Wed 18 Nov 2026 09:18 CET

Add The Local as a preferred source

Numbers that don't add up, AI maths and wildly varying projections - so why does Marine Le Pen lead the field in voter approval for her economic programme for France, asks John Lichfield.

Four out of ten voters say that they believe in Marine Le Pen’s imaginary plan to balance France’s books.

There have been many depressing poll numbers in the French presidential race. That is the most striking. Marine Le Pen leads the field in voter approval of her economic programme.

I have said it before and will say it again. Le Pen’s plans are a swindle - a bait and switch mixture of welfarism and tax cuts.

The pro-business think-tank L’Institut de l’Entreprise crunched Le Pen’s numbers and concluded that most of her €140 billion of “savings” over five years are “fragile” or fake. They amounted in truth to €7.5 billion.

The centre-left think tank Terra Nova found that parts of Le Pen’s programme had been generated by Artificial Intelligence. Her economic forecasts vary wildly from page to page. So did her numbers for projected spending cuts – sometimes shifting on the SAME page.

“After three presidential campaigns, Marine Le Pen is still not a serious candidate on public finances,” the think-tank wrote. “She says that she wants to balance the country’s books but has not got any idea how to get there.”

No matter. Marinomics is the art of making impossible things sound clever and easy. As long as the voters are taken in, why should she care?

She was at it again on Tuesday. Le Pen presented her plans for reducing the retirement age to between 60 and 62 – at a time when most other EU countries are moving towards 67.

Leave aside her projection that this would “only” cost €10 billion a year when independent estimates suggest €35 billion.

Leave aside the fact that Le Pen’s plan would force many people - especially women - to work longer than they do now to receive a full pension.

Leave aside her token but sensible proposal for a switch of 3 percent of state pensions into capital investment.

It is the principle of reducing the retirement age which is wrong. France spends a quarter of its state cash on pensions (one third of its education budget; 14 percent of its defence budget). The country needs to work more not less. Retirement at 60 to 62 is a guarantee of continuing economic decline.

Gilbert Cette, a pensions expert, told Le Monde: “This reform would impoverish the country while reducing the rights of people with broken careers, especially women.”

None of this is surprising. Le Pen’s programme is a jumble of protectionism and pro-market liberalism, lower taxes and increased social spending. She wants the voters to believe that French state finances – in deficit for half a century – can be restored without any pain for voters, rich or poor. All the suffering would fall on immigrants, fraudsters, the European Union and regional governments (which would be abolished).

In the televised mini-debate on Monday evening, the failing centrist candidate Gabriel Attal accused Le Pen of “magical financing”. Le Pen was ready for him. She demanded “modesty” from a former Prime Minister of the Macron era responsible for “the biggest debt in the history of the country”.

Touché? Yes. After running the country’s finances onto the rocks, the mainstream parties are struggling to respond to the fiscal fantasies of Le Pen and Jean-Luc Mélenchon. How can you point out that Le Pen is irresponsible when you are responsible for the mess that the country is in?

The Le Pen plan may be less extreme than that of Mélenchon but it is more dangerous. He will not be elected next May. Le Pen might be.

READ ALSO : OPINION: France's failing centre is to blame for popularity of Mélenchon's fantasy economics

Le Pen’s de facto deputy Jordan Bardella argued last summer that the RN must prepare for the shock of government. It no longer has the freedom-to-be-feckless of a permanent party of opposition. It must become economically credible. Bardella was rebuffed and his economic advisers fired.

Rather than engage in real policy-making, Le Pen and her economics chief Jean-Philippe Tanguy have produced a blizzard of nonsensical figures. Mainstream parties have spluttered; four in ten voters have cheered; the global markets have shrugged and laughed.

If Le Pen is elected, they said, she will have to change course. Remember François Mitterrand’s big U-turn in 1983? Remember how we bullied Greece in 2009?

Few voters have studied the detail of Le Pen’s dotty programme. Few have heeded the warnings of think tanks. Even fewer listen to the protests of the discredited mainstream politicians. All that could still change.

The first round of the election is five months away today. Traditionally, French voters do not think clearly about the presidential election until January or February.

There are many reasons to reject the idea of a President Le Pen: her dangerous admiration for Vladimir Putin and willingness to abandon Ukraine; her Trump-like plans to victimise legal migrants ; her proposed “French first” amendments to the constitution which would, in effect, destroy the European Union.

READ ALSO : ANALYSIS: Are Le Pen's 'French preference' plans feasible or even legal?

It is Le Pen’s economic laziness and incompetence that might come back to haunt her next Spring.

To defeat Jean-Luc Mélenchon in the two-candidate runoff on May 2nd would be easy. To defeat a credible candidate from the centre-ground, she will need the votes of older voters and the right of the centre-right. Both groups are sensitive to arguments about national, economic security, not just short-term, ephemeral personal gain.

There is no credible candidate from the centre-ground at present. Why? Where on earth can one be found? More on that next week.

For a more detailed look at Jean-Luc Mélenchon's economic programme, see last week's column .

Become a member or log in to continue reading

#Politics #Opinion and Analysis

Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at news@thelocal.com . Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in here to leave a comment.

The Local Europe AB Västmannagatan 43 113 25 Stockholm Sweden

About us Contact us News Archive Search articles Find jobs Post a job ad Advertise with us

Login Become a member Help Centre Corporate access

News Travel news Covid-19 Politics Opinion Reader questions All topics

Get daily news straight in your inbox

By signing up you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We will use your email address to send you newsletters as well as information and offers related to your account.

2026 The Local, All Rights Reserved.

Manage Cookies Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions