Takeover target Northern Star Resources has incurred a first strike after some of its shareholders protested about the bonus formula for the gold miner’s executives. The company’s remuneration report was opposed by 38.5 per cent of shareholders voting at Wednesday’s annual general meeting, easily clearing the 25 per cent threshold set by Australia’s two-strike law. The vote was not unexpected given that powerful proxy adviser ISS had recommended its investor clients vote down the report. Michael Chaney, who was succeeded as chair by Michael Ashforth after the meeting, was bemused by ISS’ rationale, pointing out the proxy adviser had taken issue with the performance targets guiding short-term executive bonuses even though they were overwhelmingly approved by shareholders at last year’s AGM. There was also pushback against two tranches of a combined 538,156 long and short-term rights potentially worth $13m to new Northern Star chief executive Suresh Vadnagra, and $4m of sign-on rights granted to him on his recruitment. However, the grants were easily approved, despite protest votes of up to 25 per cent. Mr Vadnagra was hired from Glencore to replace Stuart Tonkin, who quit in May after repeated production downgrades angered investors and ultimately drew the attention of activist investor Elliott Investment Management. After two months of sparring with Elliott’s over its demands for major change at the underperforming miner, Northern Star agreed to appoint two of Elliott’s preferred directors — Mark Cutifani and Peter Rozenauers — alongside the miner’s appointment of Terry Bowen and Jeff Quartermaine. All four were overwhelmingly endorsed by the AGM. Northern Star’s year has been further complicated by a $39 billion takeover offer in September by South Africa’s Gold Fields that was quickly rejected by the target. Mr Chaney said there had been no recent contact with Gold Fields, which has been pressured to augment its largely-scrip offer with more cash to win over Northern Star investors. However, Mr Chaney also again alluded to potential other bidders. “This is a very attractive company in terms of its assets and its jurisdictions, and it would be surprising if other companies weren’t looking at us,” he said. A priority for the new chief executive is overcoming teething problems and commissioning a new $1.8b processing plant at its flagship Super Pit in Kalgoorlie-Boulder. Mr Vadnagra told the AGM that the plant’s run-rate has improved to 72 per cent this month, from 59 per cent in October, with throughput up 15 per cent. However, “while these improvements are positive, the plant continues to experience frequent interruptions associated with commissioning and equipment-related issues”, he said. “These are impacting operating time and performance.” At its last disclosures, Northern Star’s production from Kalgoorlie for the 2027 financial year was tracking towards the lower end of its guidance range of between 550,000 and 650,000 ounces. “The ultimate outcome will depend on how quickly we resolve commissioning-related issues and improve performance,” Mr Vadnagra said. With Northern Star not ruling out asset sales, Mr Vadnagra said he was still reviewing the business “but making sure that we are extracting the most out of our assets by operating them to their full potential”. Each asset was being examined alongside opportunities to improve performance and an assessment of their strategic fit. Northern Star shares closed 1.7 per cent lower at $24.18 on Wednesday, valuing the group at $34.5b. They are off one per cent for the year, having peaked at nearly $32 in March.
Northern Star Resources cops ‘first strike’ on pay report as Chaney steps down
The company’s remuneration report was opposed by 38.5 per cent of shareholders voting at Wednesday’s annual general meeting, easily clearing the 25 per cent threshold set by Australia’s two-strike law.




