For some time we have had a Federal Labor Government that resorts too often to spin and obfuscation. Now we have to wonder if WA Labor is on the same path. That is the conclusion that can be drawn from the Cook Government’s claim that it delivered a great last-minute victory for the State in its fight with the Albanese Government over gas policy. Premier Roger Cook had shouted from the rooftops about how he was opposed to the Albanese Government’s gas reservation plan. The plan would require exporters to reserve 20 per cent of gas for domestic use and maintain a further 10 per cent as an oversupply buffer. Mr Cook insisted WA — which has had its own 15 per cent gas reserve since 2006 — should be exempt from the new scheme designed to fix an “east coast problem”. Earlier this month he called on his Federal Labor colleagues to break ranks and back amendments which would fully exempt WA from the Albanese Government’s contentious gas scheme. “I call on all WA Senators — whether they are Labor, Liberal, Green or One Nation — to put WA first and support WA jobs. . . . hands off our gas,” he said. On Tuesday Mr Cook claimed the State Government had delivered a win for WA on gas. “The Albanese Government listened to WA by separating the west coast from the east coast gas market in their draft legislation,” Mr Cook said. “They then created the ability for the Federal minister to set WA’s domestic gas supply obligation to zero under their scheme — recognising our own system is already delivering 20 per cent. “They have now proposed an amendment that would make a zero domestic supply obligation setting permanent. Together, these settings will create an effective carve-out for WA,” he said. But further scrutiny revealed that claim was tenuous as industry leaders warned the final decision on WA’s gas would still lie with Canberra. One of the ministers involved, WA’s Madeleine King, who is Federal Resources Minister, pointedly refused on Wednesday to call it a “carve-out” for the State. She rejected concerns that an exemption from the scheme for WA would also require the Energy Minister, currently Chris Bowen, to not only be consulted but be “satisfied”. That notion should ring alarm bells for WA. Then there are the wider ramifications of the proposed Federal scheme, which have sparked warnings that it would undermine domestic gas producers by forcing exporters to sell against them. Ryan Stokes, chair of Beach Energy and Seven Media Group, which owns The West Australian, warned last week that “oversupply may deliver a short-term sugar hit for buyers but it pushes down the prices producers need to justify drilling new wells”. “Less investment today means less gas tomorrow,” he said. “The only way to get more gas to market is to encourage investment, not mandate sales,” Mr Stokes said. There is significant scope for numerous unintended problems with the Federal gas reservation scheme. That is consistent with many Albanese Government policies.