Anna Alboth
November 10, 2026 08:34
Seventeen years after the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Bosnia’s constitution unlawfully discriminates against Roma, Jews and 15 other minorities, they remain barred from the country’s highest political offices.
This post is also available in this language: Bos/Hrv/Srp
In Sarajevo, the election campaign posters hang from lampposts, walls, fences and billboards. To the uninitiated, it is a jungle. At junctions, there are several, or even a dozen or so at a time: small posters, larger ones, huge billboards. Smiling men, a few women. Surnames, numbers, parties, nations. You need to know who’s who to make sense of this jigsaw puzzle.
The October 4 general elections in Bosnia and Herzegovina involved several levels of government all at once. Depending on where they live, voters chose representatives for the three-person Presidency, the state House of Representatives, the parliaments of both parts of the country – the Serb-dominated Republika Srpska and the Bosniak-Croat Federation – and the cantonal assemblies within the Federation.
But these elections were about more than simply filling a few thousand positions across several levels of government. The elections took place in the wake of one of Bosnia's most turbulent political periods in recent years. Milorad Dodik, for years the most powerful politician in Republika Srpska, lost his office as its president in 2025 following a final court ruling. His SNSD party, however, remained one of the country’s main political forces. Prior to this, the ruling coalition at state level had collapsed, and a new majority had failed to materialise.
Furthermore, Bosnia conducts its politics with Serbia on one side, Croatia on the other, and within its borders two parts of the state and three constituent nations, whose parties still largely run separate campaigns. International election observers describe a deeply fragmented political landscape, with campaign narratives still rooted in wartime divisions. The SNSD speaks of defending Republika Srpska, Croatian parties of political representation for Croats, and Bosniak parties, amongst other things, of strengthening the state and the position of Bosniaks.
In Bosnia, therefore, elections still very often begin with the question: who will represent ‘our people’?
These elections brought technological changes, too. Biometric identification and ballot scanners were introduced across the country, intended to make voting more secure and increase confidence in the process. International observers subsequently reported genuine electoral competition, but also technical difficulties and problems with ballot secrecy. The EU welcomed the new technology while acknowledging shortcomings in its implementation.
So, Bosnia is changing the way it counts votes. Changing the rules governing who can stand for high office is proving much harder.
I walk through Sarajevo, looking at all the faces staring back at me, and think of one person who is not on those posters: Dervo Sejdic.
The Bosnian constitution was drawn up as part of the Dayton Agreement, which in 1995 brought an end to the brutal wars in the Balkans. Peace had to be forged between the three warring parties, so the state was built around three ‘constituent peoples’: Bosniaks, Serbs and Croats.
The system was designed to end a war, not to create an ideal democracy. But what helped secure peace in 1995 has, over the decades, also helped entrench the very ethnic divisions it was meant to contain. Thirty-one years later, those divisions still shape the political life of this small country.
To put it simply: at the highest levels of government, the chairs are labelled with the names of the nations. The Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina has three seats: one for a Bosniak, one for a Croat and one for a Serb. The 15 seats in the state’s House of Peoples are also divided between these three groups: 3 times 5 equals 15. If you are a Romani person, a Jew or do not wish to identify as any of the three nations, you cannot stand for election to these positions. You can vote, you can become a councillor, you can work in the civil service, you can pay taxes. But you will never become president. Never. By design.
In 2006, Dervo Sejdic, Romani, and Jakob Finci, Jewish, lodged complaints with the European Court of Human Rights, or ECHR. Three years later, they won their case. The Grand Chamber of the court ruled that such exclusion constituted blatant discrimination and should be rectified.
That was in December 2009. Since then, Bosnia has held another election. And another. And another. Yet the constitutional seats still bear the same labels.
The year after he won his case against his own country in Strasbourg, Sejdic wrote to Bosnia’s Central Electoral Commission. He knew the judgement had not yet been implemented, but he thought he would ask anyway: could he, in the spirit of that judgement, stand as a candidate for the Presidency?
The reply, as he recalls it today, went something like this: “You may come; you may submit your documents. The Constitution and the Electoral Code will give you the answer.” In short: no.
Seventeen years later, I ask him: “If the ruling had been carried out back then, perhaps your face would be on those posters today. Do you ever think about that?”
“All the time,” he says. “Why should I be any worse than other presidential candidates?”
Sejdic’s case shows you can succeed before the ECHR yet, 17 years later, still be unable to exercise the right you fought for and won. The court cannot walk into the Bosnian parliament and amend the constitution. Bosnia and Herzegovina is obliged to implement its judgment, and implementation is overseen by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe. The Sejdic-Finci case has therefore been returning to the Committee of Ministers for years.
I asked the Council of Europe what exactly 17 years of waiting means. The reply leaves little room for diplomatic interpretation: “The continued retention of the present discriminatory electoral system constitutes a clear violation of the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights, going to the heart of the democratic process.”
The Committee of Ministers, which supervises the implementation of the ECHR’s judgments, has set June 2027 for its next examination of the case. If there is no tangible progress by then, it will consider further action.
The European Commission also insists that the issue remains on its agenda. “The EU has underlined the importance of implementing the Sejdic-Finci case law since the 2009 judgement of the European Court of Human Rights,” a Commission spokesperson tells BIRN. Brussels expects reforms ensuring that state institutions function without discrimination as part of Bosnia’s EU accession negotiations, it says. The constitutional changes, however, remain Bosnia’s responsibility.
In the meantime, I’m trying to understand who, exactly, can become a European here? Not in a geographical sense, because the geography is simple: Bosnia and Herzegovina lies in Europe. In 2016, it applied for EU membership; in 2022, it was granted candidate status; and in March 2024, the European Council decided to open accession negotiations. Though by the end of September, just before the latest round of elections, the negotiating framework had still not been adopted and the actual negotiations had not yet begun.
What interests me, however, is a Europe smaller than the continent and larger than the Union: Europe as the promise that a citizen is a citizen. And this is where the Bosnian problem begins. Because here, one can be a citizen whilst at the same time belong to a category which the constitution refers to as ‘others’, who include, as well as Roma and Jews, 15 other ethnic groups, such as Hungarians, Austrians or Poles.
Almir has strong facial features, a shaved head, a thin moustache and a small, neatly trimmed goatee. He wears an immaculate white turtleneck and strong perfume. There’s something of the angry young man about him: he speaks quickly, sharply, sometimes blurting out sentences as if they’d been waiting a long time for their turn. But his anger is well organised. Almir doesn’t just get angry. He breaks things down into their constituent parts, looks for the mechanism behind them, wants to know where they came from.
He was seven years old when a few boys shoved him into the boot of a car. Because he was Roma. Only seven-year-old Almir didn’t really understand what that meant yet. He liked drawing. He knew his colours: red, green, brown. When he was doing his homework after that incident, he drew a picture of himself with a brown face. That was all he understood. That was how he could explain to himself what had happened to him: he’s brown – he ends up in the boot. It was only later that his mother explained to him that they were Roma. And that not everyone likes Roma people.
Years later, Almir – now a poet, artist and activist – was tidying his flat. His mother had kept his childhood drawings. He found this one too. He looked at the brown face of his seven-year-old self. “I thought: what the fuck?” he says. This, amongst other things, later gave rise to the exhibition “U Sarajevu sve po starom” (Everything’s the same in Sarajevo).
Almir began rummaging through the archives. Together with other researchers, he delved further and further back into the history of the media. They found old texts about “Gypsies”, tales of cursed people, and pseudoscientific measurements of skulls. Then they returned to the contemporary media. The words have changed a little. The mechanism – far less so.
“Today, you can write ‘Rom’ correctly and then construct a sentence exactly the same way as a hundred years ago,” he explains. “A Rom committed a crime, a Rom caused trouble, a Rom man did something, even though his background is completely irrelevant to the story.”
Almir says that hatred is the fuel: “They – the politicians – need hatred to function.”
After one of his radio programs, he read the comments posted under his appearance. He was inundated with a wave of hatred, including death threats. I ask Almir when Roma people in Bosnia are truly treated as equals. “Erm… perhaps when they pay their taxes?” he laughs. “Obligations are equal. Rights – rarely.”
He also says something that I’ve heard in various forms during my journey through Bosnia during this election season: decisions about the Roma are still too often made by people who aren’t Roma themselves. “The biggest problem is that people who aren’t Roma work on and make decisions about Roma issues, and they think they know everything. But they don’t. Help? A food parcel? Give me a job!” he says.
According to Almir, the Roma themselves know best what they need. But here, this angry young man in a white turtleneck starts to contradict himself. Because he definitely doesn’t want to go into politics, even though many people I speak to about him would very much like him to. Almir claims that a political party means immediate division: one group will help you, whilst the rest will try to hinder you. As an artist, he prefers to be independent. But he wants the Roma to be where decisions are made. Which is exactly where he himself doesn’t want to go.
Nedzad Jusic is sitting in a restaurant in Tuzla, surrounded by his team: five well-built blokes. I joke that they look like bodyguards. “I would be lost without them!” he replies.
He’s been a city councillor in Tuzla for 12 years: “I know the power of decision-making.” There used to be 31 councillors on the council: 15 votes on one side, 15 on the other. Nedzad, a Romani man, held the 31st seat. “It was the Romani vote that made the difference!” he says proudly.
But his story began earlier. His father, born in the 1930s, finished school and in 1969 became head of the Red Cross in Tuzla. His mother, a Romani woman, also finished school, at a time when perhaps only half of all girls in the whole country were completing their education. It was she who insisted on her children’s education. Nedzad speaks of her as the driving force behind the family: her sisters and brothers were educated, followed by the next generation.
The proof is sitting at the table: the example is passed from hand to hand almost as readily as a bottle of rakija . A father shows his son. A sister shows her brother. An uncle shows his nephew. A policeman shows his daughter.
Admir Bibinovic works in the police’s criminal investigation department. He is one of only five Romani police officers in the country. At first, I thought I’d misheard. I ask him: ‘When did you ever feel equal?’ ‘Never.’ He doesn’t answer dramatically, he doesn’t pause for effect. He has never felt equal.
He went to the police academy partly thanks to a training course during which someone encouraged him to reflect on his own abilities and talents. He also had role models close to him: his uncle Nedzad and his sister. Now he wants to be a role model for his daughter himself.
I ask Nedzad whether a Romani president of Bosnia would make any difference. I expect an answer about setting a symbolic example for young people. ‘Nothing,’ he says. He isn’t interested in symbolism. He’s interested in the ability to make decisions.
That’s an important distinction. Because it’s easy, from the outside, to come up with a beautiful story: a Romani child looks at a Romani president and realises for the first time that they can become anything. Nedzad brings me back down to earth. He says that all his life he’s had to work five times as hard to prove he’s just as good as a non-Roma colleague. He wants Roma people where decisions are made, but not because they look good on a poster. It’s about hand number 31.
Twenty minutes from this table, there’s another answer to the question of representation. Kiseljak, near Tuzla. Rubbish lies wherever it’s no longer needed: by the roadside, under a fence, between houses. The locals say there isn’t even a communal rubbish container. Lake Modrac is nearby. Tourists used to come here, they say. Now part of the lake has dried up, and mosquitoes swarm over the area. The landscape looks a bit like a promise that nobody has formally revoked, but which has simply ceased to be fulfilled over time.
A smiling Salko has a few puppies and a two-week-old baby in his yard. His wife looks so young that for a moment I think of my 15-year-old daughter. We talk, of course, about the elections. The residents say they usually go. To cross out all the names on the ballot paper, so that the ballot is invalid, but has been used. So that no one can vote on their behalf. “Before the elections, big cars pull up here and say: ‘Dear Roma’. And straight after the elections: ‘Gypsies, get the fuck out’,” he says.
We walk a few steps further. Next to us, on the wet ground, sits a woman who has no home. She stares at me with a vacant gaze. The children start explaining to me where she sleeps. “Sometimes here,” one says, pointing to the canopy by the building. “Or over there,” says another, pointing to a spot under a lamppost. “When it rains, she sleeps somewhere else.” They show me one place after another with the same natural ease with which children show a visitor a football pitch, a shop or the way to school. She sleeps here sometimes. There, too. Under that roof, by that lamppost. In Kiseljak, even homelessness has several addresses.
And what about political representation? They don’t necessarily want a Romani person as their representative. “The important thing is that someone cares,” is the reply.
I ask one of the women what she would do if she became president. She looks at me in surprise. “I’d change my daughter-in-law.” We burst out laughing. And it is precisely then that the Sejdic-Finci case returns to its true proportions: here, someone asks for the paperwork to get a home. Or even the lowest-paid job. Or a school. Or transport. Someone else asks about asylum in Berlin, from where I came to visit this place. And the children point out to me the bus shelter and the street lamp under which a homeless woman spends the night.
Some residents don’t even know that the constitution prevents them, as Roma, from standing for the presidency. It’s hard to grapple with being denied the right to a position one has never even considered as one’s own. And that doesn’t mean the right is invalid. On the contrary. It merely highlights the gulf between two kinds of equality: that enshrined in a court ruling and that which you can see for yourself just by stepping outside your front door. The right to become president and the right to live as a full citizen converge here – very, very far from Strasbourg.
End of ‘care zone’
To visit Muhavera Alimanovic, one has to leave Ilijas, a town located northwest of Sarajevo, and drive uphill. Then a bit further still. At a certain point, the town ends, then public transport, then anything that could be considered a municipal service. “End of care zone,” says Muhavera, and I jot it down in my notebook.
Fourteen years ago, the authorities built a housing estate here and relocated around 12 large Roma families to it. Truly large: a dozen or so people in each. Muhavera says they had virtually no choice: it was either here or they would have had to live on the streets. We’re standing high above Ilijas. Muhavera and Jasmina are trying to show me where the housing estate actually begins. “Over there,” they say. I look where their fingers are pointing. One hill. Another. One more. “No, further on. Beyond that one.”
Bosnia is absolutely stunning from here. Green hills roll one into the next, the houses get smaller and smaller, and the road disappears amongst the trees. For a moment, I struggle with my own thoughts: how can it be so beautiful in a place where people have such a hard time?
It’s a long way to the town, about an hour and a half on foot. At first, there wasn’t even a proper road. There’s still no bus service today; it’s still a long way to the shop, a long way to school. There’s forest all around. Wild boars come right up to the houses. There’s a chicken farm nearby; when the wind blows the right way, you know it’s there without even looking. Yes, someone in the estate does have a car. They charge a fortune for a lift, perhaps knowing full well that the alternative is to walk. And then, says Muhavera, people from the city would ask: “Why don’t Roma children go to school?!”
Muhavera believes that the estate was built so far away precisely to remove the Roma from the city’s view. So that the ‘bad image’ would be hidden behind the hills. Only now do I really look at her. She’s 52, with pink nails, well-styled hair, beautiful white teeth and clean flip-flops. Everything is immaculate.
“People look at me through those nails, you know?” she says. They see a woman who looks after herself. They don’t see what she doesn’t show them. “My sadness. My illness. What I’ve been through.” She tells me about the brutal violence in her previous marriage. Then she shows me photos of her son. “I’m fighting for him. I’m only strong out of fear.”
Standing next to her is Jasmina, in a lace blouse with a necklace around her neck. She shows me a photo of her granddaughter. For a moment, I feel as though I’m looking at the youngest grandmother I’ve ever met.
They tell me that, before the elections, the distance from the city suddenly shrinks. Politicians somehow find their way through all these hills. They arrive. They promise flats, social assistance, books and school supplies for the children. Muhavera doesn’t pretend that, in poverty, a vote is something completely separate from money.
“Twenty, thirty marks,” she says. “That’s enough to buy food for today. For tomorrow…” For someone wondering what to put in the pot this evening, twenty marks isn’t a theory about the quality of democracy, but dinner.
Muhavera sees nothing wrong with a politician coming before the elections and offering something concrete. “I can vote for something good,” she says. “But then they should actually do something, shouldn’t they?”
The problem starts later. “They come. They talk. They promise. They promise. They promise. And then the elections are over and the road gets long again,” she says.
Once again, you have to climb one hill. Then another. And yet another. And once again, they’re out of reach.
There is another perspective: the Jewish one.
La Benevolencija – Sarajevo’s Jewish cultural, educational and humanitarian society – has been active in Bosnia since 1892, for 134 years. It has survived an empire, two world wars, Yugoslavia, the siege of Sarajevo and successive political regimes. Today, it is led by Vladimir Andrle, a representative of the younger generation of Sarajevo’s Jewish community. In 2022, he succeeded Jakob Finci in this role.
It is Vladimir who tells me something that none of my Romani interviewees mentioned. The problem is not merely that minorities have fewer rights. It is also about what such a system teaches the majority: if the state stipulates that certain top positions belong to three specific groups, inequality eventually ceases to look like inequality. It becomes the natural order of things.
“When we talk about equal rights for minorities, people from the three main groups hear it as though minorities were demanding greater rights,” he says. “In Bosnia, equal rights have come to mean ‘more rights’.”
Vladimir, however, immediately brings this grand constitutional issue back down to earth. For most Bosnian Jews, the Sejdic-Finci case is not an everyday topic. After all, most do not plan to become president. People work, raise children, pay their bills.
And perhaps that is precisely why it is so easy to learn to live with constitutional discrimination. It affects very few people in a very concrete way. But it says something about everyone’s place in society.
I am left with the words of the young angry man: “We’re part of this society,” says Almir. “If the Roma were to disappear tomorrow, this country wouldn’t be the same.” He begins to list them. Artists. Teachers. Journalists. People you meet at work, on the street, at school. “We aren’t on the fringes of Bosnia. We’re part of its identity.”
Minority Rights Group (MRG), which represented Jakob Finci before the ECHR all those years ago, warns that the consequences reach far beyond the Presidency.
“Continued exclusion also threatens identities, cultures and languages that have formed part of Bosnian life for centuries,” says Neil Clarke of MRG. “In particular, its impact on local economic development is driving minority youth to leave their communities and assimilate into the sectarian system.”
On this Sunday morning in October, I find myself standing in front of the parliament building in Sarajevo. It’s almost deserted. There are no MPs, no officials, no security guards letting people through the turnstiles. Just a wide square, concrete, glass and the flags of Bosnia and Herzegovina, fluttering fiercely in the wind high above the entrance.
Two blue flags fly side by side on the buildings of Bosnian institutions. The Bosnian flag: with a yellow triangle and stars. The EU flag: with a circle of 12 stars. From a distance, you might even mistake them for one another. From 2023, this is to be the official arrangement. The Council of Ministers has decided that the EU flag will fly alongside the Bosnian flag as a sign of the country’s commitment to European values: democracy, equality, non-discrimination and minority rights.
Yet it has been hoisted on the flagpole sooner than it was enshrined in Bosnia’s constitution.
Dalibor Tanić contributed to the reporting of this article.
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Berlin Process Needs to Level the Playing Field in Bilateral Disputes
US Concessions to Dodik Strengthen Moscow’s Hand in Bosnia
Bosnian Election Sees Record Low Turnout, Dodik Triumphant, Presidency Reshaped



