Editorial

One of the recurring frustrations of running an independent, left-leaning site is the reaction we invariably receive when we publish articles that are critical of a Labor government.

The response across social media is almost predictable.

“At least they’re better than the Coalition.”

That may well be true. Many of our readers believe it, and on many issues we may agree. But that is not the question being asked.

If an article examines a particular government policy, then the discussion should be about the merits of that policy – not whether the alternative government would have been worse.

Those are two entirely different conversations.

Democracy depends on scrutiny. Governments should expect their policies to be examined, questioned and, where necessary, criticised. That principle doesn’t change simply because the government happens to be one we broadly support.

In fact, it becomes even more important.