This work, which was commissioned by the National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA), has been criticised for its limited scope, as well as its great public expense, which has come as affected communities continue to struggle to recover from the flood events of 2022.

While the CSIRO has acknowledged that no amount of hard engineering would ‘flood-proof’ Lismore, computer models suggest that 10 ‘detention basins’, along with changes to the Tuckean Swamp and a second river outlet at Boundary Creek would reduce 2022 style flooding in Lismore by 2.07m, Casino by 0.95m, Kyogle by 0.8m, Coraki by 0.42 and Ballina by 0.73m.